Why Responsive Design is Overrated

B24 recently participated in a design conference in New Delhi, India. One topic of particular interest related to website design for news and media companies. While the latest buzzword responsive design was bandied about abundantly at the conference, there are several reasons that leads B24 to believe that the concept may prove to be more of a fad than a lasting design principle.

1. Performance

Whilst Moore’s Law is still applicable today, it is also important to note that the size of content and the demands on chip processors has also been increasing, and steadily so. Gone are the days of downloads measured in Kilobytes.

Even though mobile devices are more powerful now than 5 years ago, the scale of content consumed has grown. Expecting the same performance on a desktop and mobile device for the same content is not only unrealistic, it will have a direct and negative impact on user experience. This would be both in terms of speed and useability.

The separation of content and presentation is simply not good enough for the best user experience. The content has to be tailored to the device’s capabilities – something that is out of the remit of RWD (responsive web design)

2. Complexity

Responsive web design is inherently complex to implement. This complexity introduces significant inefficiencies above the content layer in order to cater for a multitude of devices.

Not only does this complexity result in challenges with respect to site maintenance, it also slows the site down. Whilst less of an issue for smaller, lower traffic websites, sites like the BBC and other large media houses that host a ton of content can grind to a halt during peak traffic periods.

Responsive Web Design image

Responsive Web Design can be both complex and expensive to implement

3. Resource intensive

As complexity increases, generally so does the implementation cost. Whilst the search for a singular solution through responsive web design may be appealing on paper, the time and money it takes to implement such solutions is rarely considered in the context of specially tailored sites for different (groups of) devices.

Both the workflows for development and testing of responsive sites are longer and more difficult for programmers to manage.

4. User experience

Ultimately, responsive web design is a one-size-fits-all approach. Such lowest common denominator strategies very rarely deliver the best user experience and responsive web design is no exception.

A simple example is that many features on mobile devices, like location-specific contextualisation aren’t implemented on responsive design websites. This is where a device specific strategy wins. While there is a different amount of work involved to develop a mobile site, these sites can be tailored to make the most use of a device’s features, screen size, software and connectivity.

An interesting analogy is looking at how Indian online casinos have evolved in terms of their design practices. The gambling industry often leads the way in terms of useability – particularly because they tend to have a very specific goal in mind in terms of user conversion and this focus guides sites like this popular website in terms of their design principles.

The online gaming industry experimented initially with responsive design and then opted for creating device specific applications and platforms instead. When asked why this was the case at the London Affiliate Conference in February 2014, the reply was consistently that the speed, layout and content had to be tailored to users on mobile devices – not just the presentation layer. It simply took users too long to find the relevant section to support conversion in the responsive model.

It is not a stretch to see why the argument above would apply to news and media companies. The biggest challenge is that they have been focused on delivering the same news content across platforms. The next step would be to consider how people currently use their devices, and for what they would like to use them for ideally. Only then can the decision be made about responsive design being a sound design principle.

Related: 80 ovr platinum quicksell madden 22, porque mi ex desaparece de las redes sociales, signs you are a high performer at work, why is my easy cheese runny, obituaries greenville, nc, lambs funeral home obituaries, richard erickson obituary, the real marie adler interview, significado del burro en la biblia, why you should never eat tilapia world truth, can you take pepcid and imodium together, , blue harbor collection white plates, how to make your own nfl power rankings, significado de antonio nombre,Related: memorial day out of office message examples, pepper’s landing old town maine, youth football camps colorado 2022, how can droughts be triggered by physical natural conditions, turtle soup riddles, rogers funeral home obituaries fall river, assault with a deadly weapon vehicle, rustic baby shower table decorations, military housing in germany, top chef ilan and elia relationship, spirit airlines pilot strike, will my bus pass be renewed automatically, harry potter fanfiction cedric kisses harry, ark how to get rid of radiation, new flats for sale glasgow west end,Related: awaiting carrier pickup for a week, jocelyn pua tulfo biography, how old is txunamy from familia diamond 2021, who does sophie marry in keeper of the lost cities, lilly wachowski before and after pictures, palo alto villas san antonio, tx, cabelas stuffer parts, girl pusher domestic violence, why is baklava so expensive, abbott rapid covid test expiration date extension, difference between achluophobia and nyctophobia, clomid pregnancy calculator, walnut hills high school directory, mon annuaire visio real notaires fr, journal gazette felony report,Related: kingdom of the spiders filming location, kicker km65 wiring diagram, rare silkie colors, wyoming junior miss pageant, craigslist boats tri cities wa, zen master cyberpunk pay or not, fidget toys for kids, chuck lorre vanity cards 1, math sense: focus on operations pdf, reverted philodendron birkin, babbel hack mod apk, mario puzo’s the godfather, coda: the death of michael corleone, kuppet ice maker not making ice, 2008 silverado trailer brake fuse location, owner finance grand lake ok,Related: outline the difference between statutory and independent service provision, aidan mcintosh hamilton, carhartt revenue 2020, live run log berlin fire department, is there a shortage of ginger ale, patio homes for sale in glenmoor farms gibsonia, pa, kissimmee, florida drug bust, blanton’s bourbon tampa, harmony stables odessa florida, city of sandy springs permit portal, new york state record retention guidelines, charlie huggins basketball camp, british fiona gallagher, izuku giant quirk fanfiction, metra train death today,Related: crested gecko breeders scotland, private mental hospital in sri lanka, keolis employee benefits, advanced domino strategy, teesside crematorium funerals this week, arabic sign language translator, fifa 22 logo png transparent, driving while intoxicated 3rd or more iat texas, barefoot aruba vs flying fishbone, kangaroo lake ca fishing report, bedford police officer, london blitz timeline, clifftop trail mono cliffs, rustic root woodbury owner dies, he ghosted me but likes my pictures,Related: savannah daisley photos, sagittarius ex girlfriend, del frisco’s double eagle nutrition facts, real estate companies with no desk fees, klipsch heresy crossover upgrade, cheating in high school statistics 2021, intern john net worth, is barium cyanide acidic or basic, magic lessons spoilers, parker truss bridge advantages and disadvantages, food carts bend, oregon, married at first sight: honeymoon island isabella and tyler, iowa high school wrestling rankings 2022, chicopee, ma obituaries, newquay aerohub advantages and disadvantages,Related: jeep m151a2 for sale in ga, nicholas thompson family, sunnyglade umbrella customer service, seattle athletic club membership cost, wanganui chronicle death notices, jewellery repairs derry, super bowl 50 squares payout, dillon high school football schedule, tambay women’s golf association, naia athletic director salary, masters track and field meets 2022, if a dog drowns will it float, how to fix underdamped arterial line, wrno shortwave schedule, what do pentecostals wear to swim,Related: should i transfer high schools quiz, how many brothers did joseph have, why is my package in barrigada, gu distribution center, j world rolling backpack replacement parts, atmega328p programming with arduino uno, thunder from down under cast, are the slaton sisters inbred, 2020 ford explorer buttons explained, james pepper rutland net worth, monroe county, pa breaking news, 2014 nissan pathfinder cooling fan recall, alcohol you later urban dictionary, baby shower venues knoxville, tn, julien baker and phoebe bridgers relationship, spiced tea recipe with tang and red hots,Related: dbt cultural appropriation, how to get capital letters on lg smart tv, trauma therapy edinburgh, marlin model 60 bullpup stock, 149th field artillery ww1, why did lorraine turner shoot herself, d2393 dental code, are there alligators in lake murray oklahoma, casio ad 1 adaptor specs, dollar general plastic candy canes, homes for rent on percival road columbia, sc, cheatham county fairgrounds, kress pompeii conservation project, what is a good realpage ai score, tampa titans aau basketball,Related: rent to own homes in jones county, ga, how to add atom network to metamask, what is mixed doubles in lending, lowrider cars for sale in california, ovc professional development scholarship program, emerge tech llc scottsdale, az, lake county record bee, casas o apartamentos en alquiler en ponce, is it illegal to kill woodpeckers in michigan, sydney sullivan wedding, how to calculate default interest rate, personal assessment of intimacy in relationships scale, busted newspaper st joseph county, hackney stabbing yesterday, uofl health human resources,Related: helgeson funeral home obituaries, ad barnes park covid testing appointment, rhodamine b extinction coefficient in water, popular 90s candy that’s 6 feet long, hyperbole in an occurrence at owl creek bridge, pinocchio jokes dirty, pink passion strain, federal inmate register code number 509, adot insurance code list, lessons from michal in the bible, ames construction north carolina, is kevin ashman leaving eggheads, , vintage christmas pixie elves, alan morrison brother of scott morrison,Related: peppertree park, fallbrook, raf benson station warrant officer, how to print 4×6 photos on microsoft word, slovak bean soup, , tony richards obituary, my lottery dream home massachusetts, guy montag character traits quotes, read the following passage from tokyo from an overflowing, erin hanson biography, bargaining power of suppliers in sports industry, virgo career tomorrow, 112 group member dies, dr brent dennis boulder city, nv, thomas spota daughter,Related: battletome: seraphon 2020 pdf, van wert county, ohio genealogical society, section 8 housing in hillsborough county, fl, accident on hwy 90 st charles parish, oxford united manager found dead, kyle polk portland oregon, st charles softball tournament, 12099528b87b5771bedade7bfd2e278 jumpsuit with skirt wedding, most annoying degrassi characters, resident portal bellamy, pioneer woman cowboy josh divorce, latest drug raids gold coast 2021, what is nylon 12 in cosmetics, bell 206 main rotor blades for sale, urban meyer house florida,Related: is la zenia boulevard open on sundays, cancel hotwire internet, is calala lane closed today, church of the open door scandal, incident in horsham today, rhode island surf soccer location, will 6 lug universal rims fit 5 lug, journeys return policy debit card, trafalgar street car park gillingham, acura mdx interior lights won’t turn off, plainfield country club membership cost, somerset county pa arrests 2022, used cars roanoke va craigslist, kennedy funeral home elkin, nc, qantas magazine advertising rates,Related: how should we celebrate our individual differences, section 8 housing listings, peter holden son of william holden, hudson and rex guest stars 2021, can a homeowner install a septic system in florida, oshkosh north football roster, henry marshall stephanie cole, fusion gym cancel membership, installing columns on concrete, nissan note steering wheel controls not working, tom tolbert grandchildren, classification of asanas ppt, slapping someone’s face in dream islam, patsy perin dubash, emperor grandfather clock value,Related: baltimore booze cruise, britney spears backup dancers names, level 3 ev charger power requirements, engagement ring with baguette band, chcp radiology program, ewtn mass and rosary today, coaching appraisal comments examples, why did mike olson leave lake street dive, quilts made with handkerchiefs, is karlye hopper married, kree thomas accola, south shore obituaries, peter giblin cowboy builders, why did grindelwald kill antonio, wow tbc classic dungeon boosting guide,Related: curiosity daily podcast cancelled, famous serial killers from north carolina, along the infinite sea ending explained, amy ratliff and mike neighbors, waterfront property big lake alaska, vitangcol husband of alice eduardo, funny scottish grace before meals, dixxon flannel releases, corsa tire manufacturer, lodi coffee nutrition facts, what does a basketball smell like, why are silver libertads so expensive, vodka in wine bottle for cruise, malia obama graduated from harvard, aqueduct track announcer,Related: current boston mobsters, best vegetables to grow in florida panhandle, baldor motors distributors in saudi arabia, strength and weaknesses of perfume, italian ice business profits, crash landing on you seri biological mother, john mcgrath principal, ian wright wife first wife, cscl intermolecular forces, frank gallagher personality type, wvu basketball recruiting espn, bardstown city schools staff directory, lake lots for sale chippewa flowage wi, desiree lindstrom house, trace armstrong clients,Related: lemongrass and horses, prisoner cell block h cast deaths, falcone crime family utica ny, who is the tallest animatronic in fnaf, johnny depp girlfriends, emissivity of stainless steel 304, george washington national forest hunting map, breadfruit tree for sale in south florida, phillies announcer fired, worms in dog poop pictures, where does taylor sheridan live, earl watson joy taylor house, what is a groomspiel new zealand, is jaywalking illegal in michigan, drake funeral home obituaries,Related: how to beat a disorderly conduct charge in georgia, valencia peanuts for boiling, american standard elevate shower walls installation, local government worksheets, vital impact gun safe manual, party of five julia and justin, the digger glasgow gangland crime, circumcision cost northern ireland, why did little luke leave the real mccoys, jill jacobson measurements, state of illinois job title search, itawamba community college academic calendar spring 2021, what happened to thomas horn, ross river virus treatment electric shock, edelweiss greater china equity off shore fund direct growth,Related: four words that describe william thatcher, oconus per diem rates 2022, why did miranda priestly smile at the end, best parking for majestic theater san antonio, brookline high school soccer, laverne cox twin brother: photos, disney world weather forecast 30 day, tinder wedding vows, counter social mastodon, andrew flanagan florence alabama, tipsy cow, middlesbrough menu, vice grip garage jessica bieri, 13 levels of organization smallest to largest, what is the active ingredient in vegamour, compliance and ethical practice in interior design,Related: chemotherapy immunotherapy certification quizlet, 99 centennial grove rd essex massachusetts for rent, kyle wilson elementary lunch menu, emily chang commercials, john singer sargent exhibition 2022, xenon therapy texas, a cell that protects the body by eating invading cells, brasstown bald weather cam, where is jfk01z distribution center, grant glaser veronica, do penguins give birth underwater, pirating and security clearance, , saniderm liquid bubble, florida dealer license regional office,Related: tupac sister net worth, non student apartments in rexburg, idaho, alabama ppt instructions 2021, chefs choice meat slicer 610 replacement parts, open casket ryan henry sister funeral, renaissance golf club haverhill, ma membership cost, what color to wear to uc football game, glen and friends cooking wiki, aluminum siding installation, used honda super cub for sale, frigidaire imk0028a ice maker kit installation instructions, another word for housekeeping items in business, appeal to heaven flag 13 branches, barack obama memoir volume 2 release date, harbor club st lucia vacancies,Related: , utopian socialism pros and cons, bundeena squid fishing, remember me poem don’t remember me with sadness, best exhaust for honda accord v6, may lake to snow creek trailhead, kirksey funeral home, mayo clinic “mandatory retirement age”, barbara jackson cartersville, ga, kevin samuels death autopsy, sanibel causeway today, penny singleton grave, spitting spider bite symptoms, mini cows for sale in california, recent drug bust in calvert county, md,Related: 14 rules of kartilya ng katipunan, resorts world core values, perth district court sentencing, idaho foster care rates 2020, top five ending, can goats eat sword ferns, allen joines first wife, operation hump survivors, le tucci restaurant london, sceptre tv blue light no picture, kevin stevens wife, farmers home furniture ultipro login, les neuf regions de l’abdomen et leurs organes, john schneider rob schneider’s brother, julien macdonald candles,Related: my indeed resume disappeared, lucy and henry on tattletales, benton harbor funeral home, total adblock customer service phone number, types of security breaches in a salon, how old is astrid cuevas, cherokee county, ga accident reports 2021, qantas business class meals, kitt shapiro rothschild, parmadale orphanage haunted, gunnison to montrose shuttle, distance from cana of galilee to capernaum, chase high school checking account, nadezhda ulyanovna klitschko, cfl practice squad salary,Related: colorado springs mayoral candidates 2023, wallander the fifth woman spoilers, direct damages in contract law, cimarron city new york, laurence ronson net worth, what rhymes with 25 for birthday, michael ansara boston, why is stuart varney not on his show this week, david rose memes, les paul traditional pro vs standard, romani actors nightwing, obscurify apple music, ratio of finance staff to employees, car accident on route 340 wv today, when heroes fly ending explained,Related: sarasota music festival fellows, aquarius 2022 horoscope, epekto ng pandemya sa pag aaral, pengeluaran sgp 49 live, how to make a private lobby in hypixel, 2020 silverado sport mode, lorenzo fertitta related to tilman, deloitte retention bonus, chicago jr blackhawks brick team, 20mm offset pan collar bunnings, univision deportes comentaristas, vivian barrett michael obituary, accidentally sent social security number in email, cairns base hospital maternity ward phone number, rust bandit camp gambling exploit,Related: henry long ranger trigger adjustment, lse development studies personal statement, trunk based development example, error while fetching extensions xhr failed proxy, adults only resorts in miami, florida, michael fishman yankees salary, archbishop cordileone opus dei, p27 baseball academy tuition cost, cypress bay high school bell schedule, sparx maths student login, grass cutting tenders kzn, why would the sheriff office call me, countess sophie racist, walsh football roster 2022, hhsrs worked examples,